city-island-bronx
Home › Neighborhoods › City Island, Bronx
Selling Your Home in City Island, Bronx
Real market data from 59 recorded property sales in City Island. See current prices by property type, seasonal trends, and what the numbers mean for your sale — backed by NYC public records, not estimates.
City Island Home Prices by Property Type
Median sale prices from 59 recorded transactions in City Island, based on NYC Department of Finance public records.
Quarterly Trend
📊 Why this data is more reliable than other sites
The numbers on this page come from the NYC Department of Finance public records — every legally recorded property sale in City Island, not just MLS-listed transactions. Sites like Zillow and StreetEasy only capture listings that go through their platforms, missing FSBO sales, off-market deals, and transfers that never hit the MLS. This dataset includes all of them, giving you a complete picture of your market.
Data source: NYC Department of Finance, Rolling Sales Data — Bronx. Period: March 2025 – February 2026. Excludes $0 transfers and non-arms-length transactions. Last updated: March 2026.
Best Time to Sell in City Island
Monthly sales volume and median prices in City Island — ★ marks peak months with the strongest combination of activity and prices.
Takeaway
In City Island, February and September showed the strongest combination of sales volume and median prices during this period. Listing during peak months means more active buyers and stronger competition for your property — which can translate to faster sales and better offers. If you're planning to sell, aligning your listing with these high-activity windows gives you the best chance of maximizing your outcome.
Housing Stock in City Island
Breakdown of 59 property sales by type — showing what's actually trading in the neighborhood.
What This Means for Sellers
Single-family homes are a significant part of the City Island market. Detached and semi-detached homes tend to attract a different buyer pool — often families seeking more space and outdoor areas. Highlighting features like yards, garages, and proximity to schools can help your listing stand out.
Frequently Asked Questions About Selling in City Island
Based on 59 recorded property sales from NYC Department of Finance public records (March 2025 – February 2026): Co-op Apartments have a median sale price of $375,000 (4 sales); Single-Family Homes have a median sale price of $617,500 (28 sales); Condominiums have a median sale price of $665,000 (9 sales). These are actual recorded sale prices, not listing prices or automated estimates.
The City Island real estate market recorded 12 sales in 2026Q1 with a median sale price of $700,000. Compared to the prior quarter, median prices were up 0.1%. With 59 total sales over the past year, the market shows healthy transaction activity. These numbers come from NYC public records covering every legally recorded sale, not just MLS listings.
Based on the past year of sales data, February and September showed the strongest combination of sales volume and median prices in City Island. Listing during peak months typically means more active buyers, stronger competition for your home, and a better chance of receiving top-dollar offers. However, every home and situation is different — Justin Braithwaite can help you time your listing based on current market conditions and your specific goals.
The City Island housing market includes: Co-op Apartments (7% of sales), Single-Family Homes (47% of sales), Condominiums (15% of sales), Multifamily & Other (31% of sales). Understanding the composition of your local market helps sellers price competitively and identify the right buyer pool.
Justin Braithwaite's listings sell in an average of 24 days on market — significantly faster than the borough average. His listings close at a 102.8% sale-to-list ratio, meaning sellers typically get more than their asking price. With 96.1% of listings closing successfully and over 261 seller transactions completed, Justin's track record speaks for itself. The key is accurate pricing, professional marketing, and expert negotiation from day one.
While you can legally sell a home in City Island without an agent, working with an experienced broker typically results in a higher net sale price — even after commission. Justin Braithwaite's sellers achieve a 102.8% sale-to-list ratio across 261 transactions and $216M+ in total sales. As a Licensed Broker and Certified Negotiation Expert with 5.0 stars across 169+ reviews, Justin combines data-driven pricing with expert negotiation to maximize your outcome. Most sellers who try to go it alone leave money on the table.
City Island, Bronx at a Glance
City Island is a small island community in the easternmost part of the Bronx, connected to the mainland by the City Island Bridge at Pelham Bay Park. The housing stock is distinctive for the Bronx — primarily single-family homes, many with a New England coastal village character, along with a growing number of condominiums and co-ops. Waterfront properties and homes along the island's main street command premium prices.
The island is approximately 1.5 miles long and a half-mile wide, with a year-round population of approximately 4,500 residents. City Island Avenue, the main street, is lined with seafood restaurants, galleries, and maritime-themed shops. The community has a strong nautical heritage, with several yacht clubs and marinas. City Island is served by the BX29 bus connecting to the 6 train at Pelham Bay Park station.
Nearby Neighborhoods
Ready to Sell Your City Island Home?
Get a data-driven strategy for your sale — backed by local transaction data and Justin's track record of 102.8% sale-to-list ratios.